Thanks mate - great questions that I should have included the answers to!
I have to say that the whole changeover flap system reminds me of a barrel of monkeys all linked together. One bit of force in the wrong direction and the whole system fails. Granted, mine is worn and well destroyed, but you can still appreciate the looseness of the whole system. It really seems cheaply made for such a complex system. Even if the ‘holders’ hadn’t come loose, the plastic would have soon worn away in other areas. It should be made of metal with proper bearings.
I did suspect there was something wrong with the manifold. Last time I had the car checked over, they noted a rattle coming from the manifold while on the dyno. I took this to mean things were getting a bit loose in there, but had no idea it was this bad.
Another interesting note is that the service centre reckoned there was a leak in the manifold top/bottom seal, because when a fluid was sprayed over certain parts of the joint, the idle would change. I didn’t see any evidence of a failed seal, but then it got pretty well destroyed when taking the manifold apart.
The car has had a CEL on for some time - related to O2 sensor out of range, and many random misfires. Interestingly I also had ‘intake flap stuck open,’ though as mentioned above, there are no sensors related to the changeover flaps, only the tumbler flaps, which seemed to be OK - at least they weren’t jammed or broken. But who knows?
I suppose that both of these issues can be explained by the manifold. Because two of the intake ports were jammed with plastic bits, it’s very possible that they were running rich into that cat, and causing the O2 sensor issues. I will report back once it’s all back together.
-P