Car totaled (08' RS4)

M3 is great. 90, 92, 46?

Ive heard nothing but good things about the E90/92. Interesting choice in CO, guess is really depends where you are though.

92 w/the Competition Package. Really ideal for snow! Went with a 6 spd. Mountain bike a decent amount and also camp on occasion. So the combination should (hopefully) work out well. Driven a stick forever (not to suggest well necessarily) but I find this to be a harder car to drive relative to the RS. More raw? Feels like it wants to be on a track. Agree with Saki, no real good alternatives for a do it all high performance sedan.

Have a favorite so far?

Leaning M3! QUIET car in stock form (until you hit about 5k RPM’s). Sounds different altogether. Fun to drive like the RS but with wholly different character. 4Runner will really come in handy though, that thing must be built like a tank. It has 170k on the clock but you would never know.

JHM has a shop 4-runner with over 300,000 miles on it.