Replaced valley pan gasket, still leaking.

I figured out the VPG was leaking so I put in a new one. I followed the torque specs and tightened every screw in order per the manual. Took the car for a drive and its still leaking, actually looks worse now. What gives? Is there something I’m missing or has anyone else experienced this issue? I’m thinking I may have just received a defective gasket, but didn’t want to order another one without asking for advice. Thanks!