I think if you can get the TIP in the same range and the manual then everyone will be happy.
Personally I started out as a manual only person having been brought up on it, learn’t and then had one for years. My daily is a slush box (and has been for 10 years). The tow car/spare is a manual which I had the misfortune to be in in peak hour 
Now for motorsport for me it’s manual all the way, and if I’m going for a cruze/blat then I’d probably prefer manual too. And also it’s fun to take one to work every now and again. However for the daily grind you can’t really beat a slushy. (I’m getting to my point)
I had a chance to drive a TIP for a weekend once and me likes. All the benefits of both with only some of the downsides … like the shift program.
I must say when I took my brothers TIP for a run the shift program was way worse than my slushbox (and it’s not a TIP)… tap … wait … wait …wait … shift. (oh there it is) If that new TIP program moves the shift up to near almost where you hit the shifter then it will be a damn good thing (I may have to steal the keys!!!) (Just kidding Jnr!)