when the B6 S4 was relatively new, some douche bought one then was telling everyone about his ‘kills’. Claimed that he raced a Ferrari (355 I think) and lost but when they raced in 3rd gear, he pulled hard. Then the moron went on and on about 3rd gear being like a secret weapon yada yada yada. Then another guy did the same, and it spawned a pretty tame by today’s standards flamefest with B5 S4 guys chiming in (because he mentioned beating a couple of B5s).
The B5 guys, hating the new car because it was well, not a B5, jumped on this opportunity to make fun of the B6 owner and use him as a poster boy for the entire B6 scene. This despite the fact the guys was never really on the forums and never really posted again.
Oddly enough the guy owned his car for like 5 minutes and moved on, yet they still reference this as if it is still relevant and/or funny. They reference it like anyone else even mentions third gear on the 4.2 side of the forums. They don’t.
Remember this was back in the day when the B6 had no real mods…other than APR/GIAC tunes and 2.25" exhaust, both of which made, as near as makes no difference, zero gains over stock, so it was easy to make fun of the platform. The B5 guys were so used to picking up 100 wtq and 70 whp from tune and piggies that the B6 was a joke as far as ‘tunability’ was concerned (even though the stock B6 would beat most stage II cars lol).
Fast forward a few years and the B5 guys love to reference it. It’s funny because you hear B5 S4 guys reference the third gear thing almost as often as you hear them mention that a stage II B5 is faster than any B6/7 S4 with exhaust/tune etc. It’s just the standard forum lore…you hear something and then hear it repeated over and over. Audiworld did a ‘test’ of a stage 0 b5, stage 1 b5, stage 2 b5 and a stock B6 when the B6 came out. The guys who ran the test ALL owned B5 S4s and were classic B6 hating trolls. Not surprisingly the B6 lost badly to everything but the stock B5. If you search the internet for races between B6/7 S4s and stage 1 or 2 B5 S4s you’ll see that the 4.2 car almost always kills the B5. Of course they never reference the facts…just the forum lore.
http://m.audizine.com/forum/showthread.php/185844-so…-what-can-our-s4-s-actually-beat-in-a-race?highlight=B6S4%203rd*%20gear&styleid=12